|
|
||||||||
Infectious Diseases Laboratories, Institute of Medical and Veterinary Science, Adelaide, South Australia 5000, Australia
Correspondence
Tuckweng Kok
tuckweng.kok{at}imvs.sa.gov.au
Received 11 January 2007
Accepted 20 February 2007
Abbreviations: FRET, fluorescence resonance energy transfer.
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The prevalence of trichomoniasis in developed countries, such as Australia, has decreased dramatically in recent years due to improved health services and treatment (Bowden & Garnett, 2000). However, rural and remote areas of Australia are an exception to this trend, with hyperendemic rates of T. vaginalis infection (Bowden et al., 1999; Knox et al., 2002). A rapid and sensitive diagnostic test using a convenient specimen (e.g. dry genital swab or urine) is needed for both patient and public health management.
Wet-mount microscopy is the most commonly employed laboratory method for diagnosing trichomoniasis (Radonjic et al., 2006). Although this test is rapid and inexpensive, it has a limited sensitivity of 2060 % (Caliendo et al., 2005; Jordan et al., 2001; Ryu et al., 1999; van der Schee et al., 1999). Culture is the current reference standard in the diagnosis of trichomoniasis, but is rarely used in routine laboratory tests (Schwebke, 2005). This technique is slow, taking up to 7 days of incubation, requires daily microscopy and is relatively expensive. In remote areas of central and northern Australia, the commercially available InPouch culture showed a sensitivity of 63 % (Smith et al., 2005).
Several PCR assays targeting various regions of the T. vaginalis genome have been described for diagnosis of this infection (Caliendo et al., 2005; Kengne et al. 1994; Lawing et al., 2000; Madico et al., 1998; Mayta et al., 2000). These studies showed a detection sensitivity by PCR in the range of 8998 %. A recent study showed that T. vaginalis DNA is undetectable after 2 weeks of treatment with metronidazole in 85 % of individuals (Van Der Pol et al., 2005).
This study reports the validation of two real-time PCRs with fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) hybridization probes for detection of T. vaginalis DNA in genital or urine specimens from female patients. The tests were compared with wet-mount microscopy and discordant results were analysed by nucleotide sequence analysis of the amplified products or a different PCR targeting a highly repetitive DNA region of the T. vaginalis genome (Kengne et al., 1994; Paces et al., 1992).
| METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
PCR primers and probes. Two real-time PCR assays using FRET hybridization probes were designed in this study to detect different genetic regions of T. vaginalis. The FRET probe technology has been used and described previously in our laboratory (Burrows et al., 2002; Stone et al., 2004). A pair of FRET hybridization probes consists of two probes, donor and sensor, each labelled with a different fluorophore (fluorescein, LC Red 640 or 705). When the probes are bound to target DNA, the donor fluorophore excites the sensor, which yields an emission fluorescence. The FRET probes and target DNA hybrids can be differentiated at a characteristic temperature (Tm) that is determined using melting-curve analysis.
The first PCR targets the ß-tubulin gene of T. vaginalis. The primers BTUB3f (5'-TCCAAAGGTTTCCGATACAGT-3') and BTUB_bkmt (5'-GTTGTGCCGGACATAATCATG-3') amplify a 195 bp sequence of the T. vaginalis ß-tubulin gene. The forward primer (BTUB3f) and FRET hybridization probes used were as described previously by Hardick et al. (2003), but the reverse primer BTUB_bkmt was a new design that provided increased test sensitivity in preliminary experiments.
In the second PCR, a different primer set was designed to amplify a 323 bp product of the 18S rRNA gene of T. vaginalis, TV16Sf-2 (5'-TGAATCAACACGGGGAAAC-3') and TV16Sr-2 (5'-ACCCTCTAAGGCTCGCAGT-3'). A new set of FRET hybridization probes was designed for the 18S rRNA gene PCR, TV16_FL (5'-CAGGTGGAAGAGGGTAGCAATAACA-fluorescein-3') and TV16_LC (5'-LC Red 640-TCCGTGATGCCCTTTAGATGCTCTG-p-3'). All primers and probes were manufactured by TIB MOLBIOL.
ß-Tubulin gene PCR. The ß-tubulin gene LightCycler PCR master mix contained the following reagents (final concentrations): 1x LC FastStart DNA Master hybridization probe buffer (Roche Diagnostics), 4 mM MgCl2, 0.5 µM of each primer, 0.2 µM BTUB FL and 0.4 µM BTUB LC. Two microlitres of template DNA was added to 18 µl master mix directly before PCR cycling was performed. Cycling conditions were as follows: 95 °C for 10 min followed by 50 amplification cycles of 95 °C for 10 s, 55 °C for 10 s and 72 °C for 10 s. Fluorescence was detected throughout the annealing phase of each amplification cycle. After amplification was complete, melting-curve analysis was performed as follows: 95 °C for 0 s, 40 °C for 60 s followed by a gradual increase in temperature (transition rate of 0.1 °C s1) to 80 °C with continual fluorescence detection. A final cooling step was then performed at 40 °C for 30 s. All steps were performed at a temperature transition rate of 20 °C s1 unless indicated otherwise. Data were analysed in the F2/F1 channel using the LightCycler software (version 3.5).
18S rRNA gene PCR. The 18S rRNA gene LightCycler PCR master mix contained the following final concentrations: 1x LC FastStart DNA Master hybridization probe buffer, 4 mM MgCl2, 0.5 µM of each primer and 0.2 µM of both FRET probes. Two microlitres of template DNA was added to 18 µl master mix directly before PCR cycling was performed. The cycling conditions and fluorescence acquisition were the same as the ß-tubulin gene FRET probe PCR, except that the number of amplification cycles was reduced to 45 and the extension phase of each amplification was performed for 13 s.
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
Specificity determination
The specificities of both real-time PCR assays were determined by testing nine bacterial species (Chlamydia trachomatis, Enterococcus faecalis, Escherichia coli, Listeria monocytogenes, Neisseria gonorrhoeae, Staphylococcus aureus, Staphylococcus epidermidis, Streptococcus group B and Streptococcus pyogenes), seven parasites (Blastocystis hominis, Dientamoeba fragilis, Entamoeba hartmanni, Enteromonas hominis, Giardia lamblia, Iodamoeba butchlii and Tritrichomonas foetus), three fungi (Candida albicans, Candida glabrata and Candida tropicalis) and three viruses (herpes simplex virus types 1 and 2 and varicella-zoster virus). All were negative in both PCR assays. Although there was amplification detected with Tritrichomonas foetus, the Tm for the ß-tubulin gene-specific primers was observed at 54.5 °C, compared with the characteristic double peak at 59 and 68 °C with T. vaginalis. The fluorescence signal and Tm of 54.5 °C obtained with Tritrichomonas foetus meant that this was not considered a specific reaction consistent with T. vaginalis.
Analysis of discordant results
The criteria for a positive result in this study were defined as wet-mount microscopy positive for T. vaginalis or positive for T. vaginalis DNA by both of the above real-time PCR assays (ß-tubulin and 18S rRNA). Specimens that were positive in only one PCR, and wet-mount-negative, were tested in a third PCR (G. Harnett, PathWest LM, Australia, personal communication) and genomic sequence analysis was used to confirm the result. The third PCR used a minor-groove-binding TaqMan probe labelled with a FAM reporter dye that targeted a highly repeated DNA sequence in the T. vaginalis genome (Kengne et al., 1994).
Preliminary tests of T. vaginalis-positive patients
Initial testing to optimize the PCR assays was performed on specimens collected from 59 patients who were positive for T. vaginalis by wet-mount microscopy. From these 59 patients, 58 genital swabs and 26 urines were collected for PCR testing. The 58 swabs consisted of 24 endocervical, 26 vaginal and 8 genital (sites unspecified) specimens.
Ninety-eight per cent (57/58) of the swabs were positive in both real-time PCR assays, whilst one wet-mount-positive swab was negative in both of the PCRs. The ß-tubulin gene PCR detected 77 % (20/26) of the urines, whilst the 18S rRNA gene PCR detected 88 % (23/26) of the urines. All urines that were negative in the 18S rRNA gene PCR were also negative in the ß-tubulin gene PCR. There were seven specimens that were negative for T. vaginalis DNA by ß-tubulin-based PCR, but three of these seven were positive by 18S rRNA gene-based PCR. These did not show PCR inhibition in the COBAS Amplicor PCR (Roche Molecular Diagnostics). The latter PCR is a commercially available kit for simultaneous detection of C. trachomatis and N. gonorrhoeae DNA with an internal control that is co-amplified to exclude possible test inhibition.
Specimen tests
Following initial testing of specimens collected from wet-mount-positive patients described above, patients with suspected T. vaginalis infection were tested to compare the sensitivities of real-time PCR and wet-mount microscopy. In total, 500 randomly selected specimens, submitted to a regional laboratory, from 500 female patients were tested with the real-time PCR assays without prior knowledge of the wet-mount microscopy results. The specimens tested for T. vaginalis DNA by real-time PCR consisted of 427 dry swabs and 73 urines. Wet-mount microscopy was performed on 403 of these patients. Wet-mount microscopy was not requested by the attending physicians with the remaining 97 specimens.
There were 29 T. vaginalis-positive results detected by wet-mount microscopy, 85 by the ß-tubulin gene PCR and 89 by the 18S rRNA gene PCR. Both PCR assays detected all of the wet-mount microscopy-positive results and the 18S rRNA gene PCR detected all of the ß-tubulin gene PCR-positive results (Table 1
). The 89 positive results obtained by PCR consisted of 74 genital swabs and 15 urines. The genital specimens consisted of 48 low vaginal, 15 endocervical and 14 genital (site unspecified) swabs.
|
Wet-mount microscopy was performed on 76 of the 89 T. vaginalis PCR-positive (ß-tubulin or 18S rRNA gene) patients (Table 1
). Wet-mount microscopy detected 29 (38 %) of these 76 PCR-positive specimens. The FRET hybridization probe PCRs targeting the ß-tubulin gene and the 18S rRNA gene showed sensitivities of 96 % (85/89) and 100 % (89/89), respectively. The prevalence, by PCR detection, of trichomoniasis was 18 % (89/500) in this study of 500 female patients. Based on the criteria of a confirmed T. vaginalis-positive (wet-mount or both PCR positive) specimen in this study, the specificity of the two FRET probe PCRs was 100 % (327/327).
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The double peak observed in the ß-tubulin PCR (see Fig. 1a
) may be caused by the T. vaginalis organism containing different alleles of the ß-tubulin gene that differ in sequence in the probe-binding region. When this occurs, a double peak may be expected, as one allele is completely homologous to the FRET probe sequences whilst the other allele contains a single mismatch. This mismatch results in a weaker thermodynamic bond between the amplified DNA and the probe, which causes the probe to separate at a lower temperature in the melting-curve analysis. Another reason for the double peak may be back-folding of the amplicon on itself downstream of the sensor probe. This back-folding of the amplicon competes with the FRET probes binding to the amplicon, creating a lowered melting peak.
Tritrichomonas foetus showed amplification fluorescence in the ß-tubulin gene PCR. However, the FRET hybridization melting-curve analysis was able to differentiate between this species and T. vaginalis because the Tm differed between the two samples (data not shown). T. vaginalis showed a characteristic double peak at 59 and 68 °C, whilst the Tritrichomonas foetus sample showed a single peak at 54.5 °C. These results showed that Tritrichomonas foetus would not be expected to cause false-positive results in the ß-tubulin FRET probe PCR. No amplification fluorescence was observed using Tritrichomonas foetus DNA in the 18S rRNA gene PCR for T. vaginalis, and no reactions were observed with the two T. vaginalis PCR tests against bacteria, viruses or other parasites.
All patients who were wet-mount microscopy-positive, but PCR-negative in urine samples, provided a genital swab. The latter was PCR-positive. This showed that the sensitivity of real-time PCR assays is lower in urine samples than with genital swabs. This is consistent with results obtained from other studies of T. vaginalis PCRs (Hardick et al., 2003; Lawing et al., 2000; Smith et al., 2005). The lower sensitivity may be due to low copy numbers present in high-volume urine samples or degradation of the T. vaginalis DNA. However, the successful use of urine samples by PCR, although not as sensitive as genital swabs, would facilitate increased diagnosis and reduce spread of this infection. Centrifuging the urine to increase the concentration of T. vaginalis DNA may be a way of increasing the sensitivity of urine testing, but this approach was not tested in this study. The use of spun urine for wet-mount microscopy has a reported sensitivity of 64 %, and 73 % by vaginal fluid, compared with culture (Borchardt et al., 1997) and 51 % compared with PCR (Lawing et al., 2000). It would be expected that a similar approach may increase PCR sensitivity.
Because of the previously published low sensitivity of culture compared with PCR (Smith et al., 2005), culture was not used in this study. The requirement for prompt culture of specimens collected from patients in remote regions precluded the use of this test. Wet-mount microscopy, which is commonly used in routine tests, showed a sensitivity of 38 % compared with PCR. Among the main factors that contribute to low test sensitivity with wet-mount microscopy may be the use of dry swabs or delayed transportation of the specimen to the laboratory. However, in this study, there were no records of the types of swabs used or delay before the specimen was tested. The low sensitivity of wet-mount microscopy makes it unsuitable as the only test for laboratory diagnosis of trichomoniasis.
The real-time PCR assays described in this study showed a high sensitivity (96100 %) and specificity of 100 % for detection of T. vaginalis DNA. The prevalence of trichomoniasis was 18 % (89/500) in this study of 500 female patients. The high prevalence of this sexually transmitted infection probably results from the increased detection sensitivity of PCR compared with wet-mount microscopy. The high sensitivity and specificity of PCR reported in this study would offer a useful rapid screening tool. This could reduce spread and transmission of the infection, in particular from asymptomatic patients.
| ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS |
|---|
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
J Sobngwi-Tambekou, D Taljaard, M Nieuwoudt, P Lissouba, A Puren, and B Auvert Male circumcision and Neisseria gonorrhoeae, Chlamydia trachomatis and Trichomonas vaginalis: observations after a randomised controlled trial for HIV prevention Sex Transm Inf, April 1, 2009; 85(2): 116 - 120. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| INT J SYST EVOL MICROBIOL | J MED MICROBIOL | MICROBIOLOGY | J GEN VIROL | ALL SGM JOURNALS |