|
|
||||||||
Department of Microbiology1 , Medicine2 , Orthopedics3 , Surgery4 and Urology5 , BLDEA's Shri B. M. Patil Medical College, Bijapur 586 103, Karnataka, India
Correspondence
Basappa G. Mantur
drbgmantur{at}rediffmail.com
Received 19 March 2005
Accepted 10 March 2006
1 : 160, 490 cases) and rising titres from insignificant titres (four cases) by serology and for one case by blood-culture isolation alone. Blood cultures were carried out in 345 cases, of which 191 cases (55.3 %) yielded Brucella melitensis. In 77/79 cases undertaken for follow up, there was a steady fall in 2-mercaptoethanol (2ME) agglutination titres along with clinical improvement (P <0.01). SAT titres remained detectable in most cases for a longer period in spite of an effective antimicrobial therapy and clinical recovery. A substantial number of patients (84.2 %) presented with fever, this being the only complaint in 51.1 % of the cases. Complications were present in 8.8 % of the patients (arthritis excluded): this included the unusual complications of hydrocele (two cases), StevensJohnson syndrome (one case) and urinary tract infection (one case). Brucella agglutinins were demonstrated in synovial, testicular, hydrocele and cerebrospinal fluids. There was no clinical suspicion of brucellosis in 439 cases (88.7 %) and the diagnosis was made only by routine serology. A two-drug regimen for 4284 days with a follow-up 2ME test resulted in lower levels of relapse. These results suggest that, in endemic areas of the world, it should be mandatory to screen routinely for brucellosis due to protean clinical manifestations.
Abbreviations: CSF, cerebrospinal fluid; 2ME, 2-mercaptoethanol; RBPT, Rose Bengal plate agglutination test; SAT, standard tube agglutination test.
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Human infection can occur through consumption of infected raw milk, raw milk products and raw meat. Other means of infection include skin abrasions and inhalation of airborne animal manure particles. In addition, occupational exposure of abattoir workers, veterinarians and laboratory technicians can result in transmission of the disease through contaminated aerosols. Transmission of B. melitensis from person to person has also been reported in the literature (Mantur et al., 1996; Wyatt, 1996). Brucellosis may present clinically as acute, as chronic following an acute attack or as chronic and of insidious onset. Human brucellosis is a multisystem disease that may present with a broad spectrum of clinical manifestations and its complications can affect almost all organs and systems with varying incidence (Andres Morist et al., 2003; Cesur et al., 2003; Gur et al., 2003). Its clinical manifestations and focal complications are often troublesome in making a clinical diagnosis. Its diagnosis therefore requires microbiological confirmation by means of isolation from blood culture or demonstration of the presence of specific antibodies by serological tests. The diagnosis of brucellosis based exclusively on Brucella isolation presents several drawbacks. The slow growth of Brucella in primary cultures may delay diagnosis for more than 7 days (Yagupsky, 1999). Also, blood-culture sensitivity is often low, ranging from 50 to 90 % depending on the disease stage, Brucella species, culture medium, quantity of circulating bacteria and the blood-culture technique employed (Mantur & Mangalgi, 2004; Yagupsky, 1999). Hence, serological tests play a major role in cases when the disease cannot be detected by blood culture. However, the interpretation of these tests is often difficult, particularly in patients with chronic brucellosis, in reinfections and relapses, and in areas of endemicity where a high proportion of the population has antibodies against brucellosis. Debate continues regarding the best antibiotic combination for the treatment of human brucellosis (Bayindir et al., 2003; El Miedany et al., 2003).
This paper analyses our experiences of the past 16 years with human brucellosis in adults presenting with protean clinical manifestations and the diagnostic challenges faced in an endemic area. The serological screening method was employed for initial case identification of brucellosis in this endemic area. Positive cases detected by this screening method were then subjected to standard tube agglutination and 2-mercaptoethanol (2ME) agglutination tests for interpretation and to establish the diagnosis of brucellosis in this area.
| METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
For nine cases of epididymo-orchitis (eight seropositive, one seronegative), clear aspirate obtained from the testes was used instead of serum in the above tests using the same procedure. In addition, semen samples were obtained from eight patients: one drop of a 1 % solution of sodium azide was added to 1 ml semen and left for 30 min. The samples were centrifuged at 75 g (R4C; Remi) for 10 min and the supernatant fluid was used instead of serum in the above-mentioned tests (Brinley Morgon et al., 1978).
The following samples from seropositive patients were also tested for evidence of brucellosis using the above techniques: 32 knee joint fluid samples, two ankle joint fluid samples, seven cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) samples and two hydrocele fluid samples.
2ME agglutination test. All of the 517 sera found to be positive by the screening test were tested in parallel with the 2ME agglutination test. 2ME agglutination was performed with B. abortus plain antigen, except that 2ME was added to each tube to a final concentration of 0.05 M (Buchanan et al., 1974).
Paired sera available from 217 patients were tested for SAT and 2ME titres. Multiple sera were also tested during follow up for both SAT and 2ME titres in 79 cases; the follow-up period ranged from 14 to 720 days with a median follow up of 106 days.
In addition to the above, 102 family members of 18 indexed, bacteriologically confirmed cases were also investigated for evidence of brucellosis.
Isolation and identification of Brucella. Blood cultures were performed from 345 cases, which included 15 patients who had insignificant SAT titres of 1 : 20 and one patient with seronegative epididymo-orchitis due to clinical/epidemiological indication. Venous blood (5 ml) was inoculated aseptically into the broth phase of Castaneda's biphasic medium containing brainheart infusion agar and broth or trypticase soy agar and broth (High Media) in duplicate. The media were incubated at 37 °C with and without a CO2 atmosphere and examined for bacterial growth once a day for 30 days, tilting the broth/blood mixtures over the solid phase every day.
A number of other samples (nine bone marrow, nine testicular fluid, 34 synovial fluid, eight semen, seven CSF, two hydrocele fluid and two ascitic fluid) were also cultured using Castaneda's biphasic technique as described above.
Identification of Brucella strains was done using standard classification tests, including Gram staining, a modified ZiehlNeelsen stain, growth characteristics, oxidase activity, urease activity, H2S production (4 days), dye tolerance such as basic fuchsin (1 : 50 000 and 1 : 100 000) and thionin (1 : 25 000, 1 : 50 000 and 1 : 100 000) and seroagglutination. B. abortus and B. melitensis monospecific antisera (Murex Biotech) were used for seroagglutination tests. Isolates were sent to IVRI, Izatnagar, India, for confirmatory identification.
Statistics. To determine the significance of the difference between the performance of the two agglutination tests (SAT and 2ME) and the level of antibodies at different stages of follow up, an analysis of variance was applied. A value of P <0.05 was considered significant.
| RESULTS AND DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The diagnosis of brucellosis was established in 495 patients (1.8 %) based on diagnostic titres (
1 : 160, 490 cases) and rising titres from insignificant titres (four cases) by serology and for one case on blood-culture isolation alone (seronegative epididymo-orchitis). The data clearly elucidate the endemicity of brucellosis in this area as shown by the occurrence of cases throughout the year, although a small peak was observed in the months of July and August. Calving of farm animals usually occurs in April and May in this area, which could explain the peak incidence of human brucellosis seen in July and August in this study. The reported incidence and prevalence of the disease vary widely from country to country. Karabay et al. (2004) have reported a low prevalence of 1 % in certain areas of Turkey, which is lower than the prevalence reported here, although another study from Turkey (Sumer et al., 2003) and one from Saudi Arabia (Al-Sekait, 1999) have reported higher prevalences of 3.2 and 4.5 %, respectively. This difference in endemicity may be due to the prevalent practices in the population and also the incidence of brucellosis in the community. We were able to detect an additional seven cases of brucellosis, five of which were bacteraemic, from household members of 18 indexed, bacteriologically confirmed cases. Symptomatic infection among other family members was quite common. Almuneef et al. (2004) have also reported similar findings. This finding reflects the value of screening family members of index cases of acute brucellosis in an endemic area to pick up additional unrecognized cases. This must be taken into account by the physicians caring for these patients, so that timely diagnosis and provision of therapy occur, resulting in lower morbidity.
Four cases with non-diagnostic SAT titres of 1 : 20 revealed rising titres in paired sera from the four cases, along with positive blood cultures in two. Our data clearly indicate that SAT titres of <1 : 160 cannot always be disregarded without follow up. Conversely, SAT titres of
1 : 160 do not always signify active infection, especially in Brucella-endemic areas. The SAT measures the total amount of agglutinating antibodies (IgM and IgG), whilst the 2ME agglutination test measures IgG antibodies only. This differentiation is important, as IgG antibodies are considered a better indicator of active infection than IgM and the rapid fall in the level of IgG antibodies is said to be prognostic of successful therapy (Buchanan & Faber, 1980). A survey conducted by Almuneef & Memish (2002) in Saudi Arabia found various levels of Brucella SAT antibodies in many clinically cured patients. Seventy-nine patients diagnosed as having active brucellosis in the present study were followed up for different lengths of time (median follow up of 106 days) and monitored for Brucella antibodies by SAT and 2ME agglutination. In most cases, Brucella SAT titres remained measurable, in spite of falling to low levels (Fig. 1
) ranging from 1 : 160 to 1 : 640 (significant titres), despite an effective therapy and clinical cure. This emphasizes the overdiagnosis and diagnostic challenges faced in an area where typhoid, malaria, tuberculosis and rheumatoid arthritis clinically mimic human brucellosis, thereby exposing/denying patients access to specific therapy. However, a remarkable finding of our study was that there was a sustained drop in 2ME titres in 97.5 % of cases (Fig. 1
, P <0.01), reflecting the importance of the 2ME test for diagnosis of brucellosis in conjunction with the SAT, as well as for follow up of brucellosis in Brucella-endemic countries. Gazapo et al. (1989) claimed that ELISA was an excellent method for follow up of brucellosis; however, the results of our study clearly indicate that the 2ME agglutination test is a useful assay, as it is inexpensive and technologically simple with stable reagents. All 494 patients had an active infection, as determined by the presence of 2ME titres (IgG) ranging from 1 : 20 to 1 : 5120 with a geometric mean titre±SD of 1 : 131±641. The disease is notorious for its relapses (Bayindir et al., 2003; El Miedany et al., 2003). In the present series, only two patients relapsed. Extending treatment for longer than previously recommended (6 weeks) results in an incidence of relapse significantly lower than for shorter courses of treatment. No relapse was seen for up to 6 months of follow up in all of the patients who completed therapy for 6 weeks in a study by Gaafar (1997). The median duration of therapy and follow up of patients in the present study was 49 and 106 days, respectively. Another important finding of this study was seronegative (RBPT, SAT, 2ME test, Coombs test) brucellar epididymo-orchitis reported in one patient. Patients with acute or subacute brucellosis may, on rare occasions, fail to mount a humoral-mediated immune response. In the literature, however, there are reports of cases of brucellosis associated with seronegativity (Potasman et al., 1991; Yavuj et al., 2004). It appears clear that seronegativity may be a possibility in cases of brucellosis presenting with atypical lesions. However, our case was unique in that Brucella agglutinins were detected by the RBPT and SAT in the testicular fluid. Prozone, a commonly reported phenomenon in brucellosis (Young, 1983), was seen in only three cases in the present study up to a dilution of 1 : 640.
|
There was a predominance of males in this study. Human brucellosis affects all age groups (Sauret & Vilissova, 2002). Men between the ages of 15 and 86 years accounted for 390 of the cases, with a mean age of 31 years. The most common ages involved in this study were adolescent and young adults, as has been described in other studies (Gaafar, 1997; Madkour et al., 1985). This reflects the magnitude of the socio-economic impact of brucellosis in this area, as it affects mainly the most productive group in the community. We found that sexual intercourse was implicated as a possible means of transmission in six cases, in addition to the well-established modes of transmission.
As shown in Table 1
, the overall clinical picture of brucellosis in our study was very similar to that reported by workers elsewhere in the world (Barroso et al., 2002; Gaafar, 1997; Namiduru et al., 2003). In 88.7 % of cases (Table 2
), there was no clinical suspicion of brucellosis and in 1.2 % of cases, brucellosis was placed as a differential diagnosis in either second or third place. The illness was acute in 310 cases (62.6 %), subacute in 146 (29.4 %) and 39 (7.8 %) had chronic brucellosis. A substantial number of patients (84.2 %) presented with fever, with fever being the only complaint in 51.1 % of the cases. Joint pain alone was found in 29 cases, and in 22 cases low backache alone was recorded. The clinical features in human brucellosis are protean and therefore a number of infectious and non-infectious diseases may mimic brucellosis clinically. Medical literature reports underdiagnosis of brucellosis cases, which was clearly shown in our study where 88.7 % of cases would have been missed if routine serological surveillance had not been done. Routine serological surveillance is not practised even in Brucella-endemic areas, and we suggest that this should be a part of laboratory testing coupled with a high index of clinical suspicion to improve the level of case detection. In our study, B. melitensis was recovered from the synovial fluid of 21/34 (61.7 %) brucellar arthritis patients. This is similar to another study (Yagupsky & Peled, 2002). It is worth noting that Brucella agglutinins were demonstrated in the synovial fluid of all 34 patients in the present study. There is no report of the demonstration of Brucella agglutinins in joint fluid in the literature. Seropositivity for human immunodeficiency virus was also found in 17 brucellosis patients. There was no diagnostic/therapeutic difficulty, as has been noted in the literature (Moreno et al., 1998; Paul et al., 1995; Pedro-Botet et al., 1992).
|
|
|
All 495 patients received a standard regimen of two drugs consisting of tetracycline orally (2 g per day in four divided doses) for 4284 days together with streptomycin (0.751 g per day intramuscularly) for the first 1428 days depending on resolution of signs and symptoms. Rifampicin (450600 mg per day orally) was also added for the treatment of meningitis and meningoencephalitis. Rifampicin (600 mg per day orally) was added to the above two-drug regimen extending therapy for a further 84 days to treat the relapsed cases and the outcome was remarkable.
In conclusion, laboratory surveillance in endemic areas is essential for the diagnosis and effective treatment of protean human brucellosis. Development of new specific and cost-effective diagnostic algorithms for developing countries needs to be carried out, along with rapid and sensitive laboratory tests including molecular methods, to decrease morbidity in the endemic population. Although PCR is promising, standardization of the extraction methods and the set up is lacking and a better understanding of the clinical significance of the results is still needed (Navarro et al., 2004). The use of molecular methods in endemic areas needs to be explored before they can be used in these areas to diagnose brucellosis.
| ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS |
|---|
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
N. V. Tikare, B. G. Mantur, and L. H. Bidari Brucellar Meningitis in an Infant--Evidence for Human Breast Milk Transmission J Trop Pediatr, August 1, 2008; 54(4): 272 - 274. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| INT J SYST EVOL MICROBIOL | J MED MICROBIOL | MICROBIOLOGY | J GEN VIROL | ALL SGM JOURNALS |