|
|
||||||||

Ahfad University for Women, PO Box 167, Omdurman, Sudan
Correspondence
Abdallah el Harith
harith17{at}yahoo.com
Received 1 June 2006
Accepted 1 July 2006
Abbreviations: DAT, direct agglutination test; FD, freeze-dried; FF, formaldehyde-fixed; GP, glycerol-preserved; ROC, receiveroperating characteristics; VL, visceral leishmaniasis.
Present address: Wijngaard 155, 8212 CJ Lelystad, The Netherlands. ![]()
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In comparison with the rK39 strip/dipstick and urine latex agglutination, the DAT appears to be the simplest technique for reproducible results, as identification and production of unique antigens or antibodies requires sophisticated equipment and a certain level of skill. Thus, local DAT production has been achieved satisfactorily by a number of research groups in endemic areas (Pal et al., 1991; Mbati et al., 1999; Bimal et al., 2005; Singh et al., 2005).
To maintain DAT stability in adverse temperatures, freeze-drying of the antigen was introduced to test procedures (Meredith et al., 1995). However, the application of freeze-drying to fragile promastigotes is difficult to achieve successfully under laboratory conditions in developing countries. A simple and economical alternative method using glycerol as a thermo-protectant has therefore been developed and evaluated against a commercialized DAT freeze-dried kit at the laboratory level with favourable results (el Harith et al., 2003).
The objective of this study was to determine more realistically the stability of the glycerol-preserved (GP) antigen under ambient conditions in one of the health settings in Gedaref state, a major VL-endemic area in eastern Sudan.
| METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
50 km south-east of El Gedaref, the state capital, and a similar distance from the Sudanese border with Ethiopia. The ambient temperature declines to 28 °C from October to February, but fluctuates between 35 and 47 °C from March to November. Compared with hospitals in the Sudanese Eastern province, the existing hospital in Doka is considered to be of moderate capacity (5060 beds). Among other essential facilities, the laboratory attached to the hospital is equipped with a refrigerator operating on rationed (911 h per day) electric power and a solar-energy-powered freezer (20 °C).
The inhabitants residing in Doka area are well aware of kala-azar or VL, the symptoms of the disease and the subsequent risks if the disease is left untreated. Patients who develop fever for 2 or more weeks and do not respond to anti-malarial drugs are therefore less hesitant in reporting to the peripheral hospital. These patients are additionally encouraged by the knowledge that diagnosis is becoming less invasive and less painful and that treatment is free of charge. On average, 520 patients with symptoms resembling VL are received daily at Doka hospital.
Our study was facilitated by an ongoing VL epidemiological project undertaken by the Institute of Endemic Diseases, University of Khartoum, in the same area. By coordination with the Institute of Endemic Diseases and organizing orientation meetings with health authorities in Gedaref state on the nature and objectives of our study, the necessary permission was granted by the kala-azar National Control Programme Coordinator. Due to ethical and financial restrictions, we were not able to perform prior human immunodeficiency virus/AIDS testing on suspected VL cases enrolled in the study.
From September 2004 to October 2005, six visits of 24 weeks duration were made by our team to Doka peripheral hospital.
Enrolment of patients. Of 308 suspected VL patients received at the peripheral hospital, 204 were males and 104 females. Their ages ranged from 3 to 40 years. Almost all patients manifested spleen and/or lymph node enlargement in addition to fever. Patients and/or their guardians were informed about the possibility of VL and how the diagnostic procedures would be performed. With the patient's consent, 5 ml venous blood was collected, followed by aspiration of one or both inguinal lymph nodes. Patients with negative Giemsa-stained smears (read independently by at least two observers) in the first examination were subjected to a second or third lymph node aspiration. With the exception of six patients diagnosed either by bone marrow (3) or spleen (3) aspiration at the central hospital in Gedaref, the remaining 302 patients were assessed by the above protocol.
Sera were separated from the blood samples using a manually operated centrifuge and each sample was divided into two portions for direct testing with DAT at Doka peripheral hospital or freezing at 20 °C (solar-powered freezer) until cold-chain transportation to the central laboratory in Omdurman.
Patients with positive lymph node, bone marrow or spleen aspirates or with positive VL clinical presentation and a DAT titre of
1 : 3200 (el Harith et al., 1988) were put on a 30 day treatment course with sodium stibogluconate (Pentostam; Albet-Davis SSG). All other patients who were assessed to be negative for VL were advised to seek further medical care in the state central hospital in Gedaref.
Preparation of DAT antigens
Formaldehyde-fixed (FF) antigen.
Promastigotes of Leishmania donovani (strain MHOM/68/1-S; an isolate from a VL case in Sudan) were mass cultured in liver infusion/tryptose medium supplemented with 10 % fetal calf serum and processed according to the improved DAT procedures described previously (el Harith et al., 1995). The stained promastigote suspension was washed and finally resuspended in 1.2 % (v/v) formaldehyde/citrate saline as 10x concentrated stock antigen (5x108 promastigotes ml1).
Following a similar protocol, 17 valid DAT antigen batches varying in volume from 176 to 3200 ml (sufficient for testing of 290 to 5300 patients, respectively) were successfully produced in our laboratory over the period 19992005 (el Harith et al., 2002; and unpublished data). The reliability of this in-house-produced antigen (including the current study) was evaluated against standard control sera from eight healthy subjects and eight confirmed VL patients.
For this study, two stock FF antigen suspensions of 80 ml each (5x108 promastigotes ml1) were prepared according to the standard procedures described above and stored at 4 °C in the central laboratory in Omdurman until required.
Glycerol-preserved (GP) antigen. The procedures followed for DAT antigen preservation were as described by el Harith et al. (2003) except that the glycerol concentration was increased to 75 % (v/v). A glycerol concentration of 75 % was used in this study following favourable results obtained at a challenging temperature of 50 °C for at least 52 days (unpublished data).
Eighty millilitres of the final FF antigen was centrifuged (3200 g) for 10 min at 4 °C and resuspended in 20 ml 1.2 % (v/v) formaldehyde/citrate saline to which 60 ml glycerol (propane-1,2,3-triol; Philip Harris) was added. The antigen/protectant suspension (10x concentrated stock antigen) was mixed thoroughly and divided into 1.8 ml aliquots. Twenty of the aliquots were transported (without cooling) in September 2004 to Doka peripheral hospital where they were kept at ambient laboratory temperature (2847 °C) throughout the study period (13 months). Another 20 aliquots were kept at ambient temperature at the central laboratory in Omdurman (2537 °C) with or without air-conditioning.
Freeze-dried (FD) antigen. A total of 110 vials of 5 ml FD antigen (lot no. 1001) were purchased via the East Mediterranean Regional Office of the World Health Organization in Cairo. Following the instructions provided, the FD antigen was stored at ambient temperature in the central laboratory in Omdurman (with or without air-conditioning: 2537 °C) or in the peripheral hospital in Doka (2847 °C).
By applying a similar diagnostic dose (0.6 ml per test) to the in-house GP- and FF-produced antigen versions, the cost of using the FD kit was US$2.96 per patient.
On arrival at the peripheral hospital in Doka, reconstituted samples from the GP, FD and FF antigens were examined microscopically to ensure the absence of promastigote clump formation (autoagglutination) or lysis due to transportation.
DAT. One day before the DAT was carried out, the GP and FF stock suspensions were reconstituted by the addition of nine equal volumes of 1.2 % (v/v) formaldehyde/citrate saline (el Harith et al., 2003). These reconstituted antigen aliquots were left overnight at ambient temperature (GP) or at 48 °C (FF). Reconstitution of the FD antigen was carried out according to the instructions provided. Five millilitres of physiological saline (0.9 % NaCl) was added to each vial 510 min prior to the DAT, followed by occasional gentle mixing. Similar test procedures were followed in the central laboratory in Omdurman. Gelatin was used as a serum diluent for the GP and FF antigen preparations (el Harith et al., 1995). For the FD antigen, the serum diluent was prepared according to the instructions provided (Meredith et al., 1995).
Standard positive and negative serum samples were included in each DAT. Irrespective of the antigen version used, twofold dilutions of sera were tested from a dilution of 1 : 100 up to 1 : 102 400. After addition of the respective antigens, microtitre plates were shaken manually for 12 min. The development of a reaction was observed at
1 h intervals during the day. Following overnight incubation at ambient temperatures (health setting: 2847 °C; central laboratory: 2537 °C), test results were read visually (against a white background) by at least two observers. The end point was estimated by localizing a clear sharp-edged blue spot (in contrast to a clear colourless supernatant) identical to that observed in the control well; the preceding dilution was taken as the titre of the serum sample. Patients showing titres of
1 : 3200 were considered to be VL (sero)positive (el Harith et al., 1988).
Data analysis.
If normally distributed, numerical variables were calculated as means±SD; otherwise, they were calculated as median and quartile values. Mean values were compared using Student's t-test and medians using the MannWhitney U-test, at a critical
-level of 0.05; all tests were two-tailed. The reproducibility of the GP, FD and FF result values obtained in the peripheral hospital and the central laboratory was assessed by Cohen's kappa. The sensitivity and specificity of the GP, FD and FF antigens were estimated as percentages of the true (parasitologically confirmed) positives or negatives with exact binomial 95 % confidence limits. To determine the ideal DAT cut-off value for the three antigens in the peripheral hospital and central laboratory, a receiveroperating characteristics (ROC) curve was constructed (Fletcher et al., 1982). For comparison of differences among the diagnostic results obtained with the three antigen preparations, a BlandAltman plot was applied. Data were analysed with the STATA software program for Windows.
The small size of the study population and the high correlation between variables did not allow a valid latent class analysis to be carried out.
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Of 302 suspected VL cases examined in Doka peripheral hospital and six in Gedaref central hospital, 174 (56.5 %) had negative organ aspirates. Regardless of the antigen preparation used, all 174 also scored unambiguous negative DAT titres (1 : 1001 : 400) in the peripheral hospital, as well as in the central laboratory. The results obtained in 87 (28.2 %) patients who tested positive in the DAT (titres of 1 : 32001 : 102 400) against the GP, FD and FF in both the peripheral and the central laboratory settings were also in agreement with the positive organ aspirate results. Despite this high degree of concordance (261/308, 84.7 %), some discrepancy between the results of organ aspiration and the DAT results was observed in 18 (5.8 %) other patients. Eight of these had a positive organ aspirate (seven lymph nodes and one spleen) but a negative (1 : 1001 : 400) or marginally negative (1 : 8001 : 1600) DAT reading against all three antigens in the two settings. Despite negative lymph node aspirate results in the remaining ten patients, positive DAT readings (1 : 32001 : 102 400) were recorded for all three antigen preparations. For the remaining 29 patients (9.4 %), concordance or discrepancy between the results of the DAT and organ aspiration was dependent on the individual antigen preparation used and/or the health setting.
No significant difference was observed between the mean titres obtained with the GP and FD antigen preparations in the peripheral hospital (P=0.945) or in the central laboratory (P=0.074). However, there was a slight but significant difference between the FF and GP antigen preparation mean titres in both the peripheral hospital (P=0.019) and the central laboratory (P=0.000); four (1.3 %) patients tested negative with the GP antigen but positive with the FF antigen in both settings. Despite this difference, DAT readings obtained with the three antigens in the vast majority of patients (304/308, 98.7 %) showed excellent agreement between antigen preparations at both the peripheral hospital and the central laboratory (weighted kappa>0.90). When parasitology was taken as the gold standard and a titre of 1 : 3200 was taken as the cut-off point, comparable sensitivities of 86.7, 87.6 and 89.5 % were obtained with the GP, FD and FF antigen preparations, respectively, in the peripheral hospital (Table 1
). At this cut-off value, specificities of 92.1, 92.6 or 92.6 %, respectively, were obtained in the patient group with negative lymph node aspirate results. At the lower but optimal cut-off point established by ROC analysis (1 : 4001 : 800), higher sensitivity levels (90.596.2 %) were estimated for all three antigen preparations. Similar high levels of specificity (94.696.5 %) could be achieved if the ten patients who were misdiagnosed by lymph node aspiration (as a result of clinical presentation, positive DAT readings and a favourable response to chemotherapy) were classified as genuine VL cases.
|
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In agreement with observations in previous studies where the DAT antigen (at promastigote concentrations of 5x107 or 2x108 ml1) was employed, provisional diagnostic results could be obtainable with the GP antigen within 23 h of incubation (el Harith et al., 1988, 2003; Schoone et al., 2001). For the FD antigen, this rapid diagnostic time could not be achieved and the appearance of a diffuse blue background in the DAT (with blurring of blue spots in negative wells) implied possible alterations in the parasite membrane or loss of the Coomassie blue stain. This may be because lowering of temperatures to the levels required for freeze-drying (80 to 85 °C) in the absence of cryoprotectant can be injurious and even lytic to cells (Coriell, 1979).
Even at fluctuating ambient temperatures of 2847 °C in the peripheral hospital, the GP antigen demonstrated a sensitivity level (86.7 %) comparable to that of the FD antigen (87.6 %) kept under similar conditions and with that of the FF antigen (89.5 %) at an optimal temperature of 48 °C. Although this level of sensitivity seems reasonable, it is still below those reported in studies where bone marrow or spleen aspiration was employed as the gold standard (el Harith et al., 1988; Boelaert et al., 1999; Osman et al., 2000). In this study, lymph node aspiration missed ten (8.7 %) of the patients in whom all three antigen preparations scored positive DAT readings and in whom a favourable response to specific anti-leishmanial chemotherapy was evident. If clinical cure rather than positive parasitology was taken as the gold standard in these ten cases, slightly higher sensitivity (87.8, 88.7 and 90.4 %) and much higher specificity (96.9, 97.4 or 97.4 %) levels for the GP, FD or FF antigens, respectively, could be attained, even at the peripheral hospital.
A titre range of 1 : 4001 : 800 determined by ROC analysis was found to be optimal as the cut-off point for all three antigen preparations. We believe that this is a more realistic value, since, in this area of Sudan, no authentic case of family-related Trypanosoma infection has been reported so far (which can cause cross-reactivity). Based on this realistic cut-off point and taking a positive response to chemotherapy as the gold standard, diagnostic efficiencies (sensitivity and specificity
90 %) closely matching those obtained at the central laboratory could be reached at the peripheral hospital (el Harith et al., 1988, 1995; Boelaert et al., 1999; Osman et al., 2000). It is generally accepted that the reliability of DAT for VL detection depends to a large extent on the quality of antigen and on the area in which the VL study is carried out. When using trypsinized Leishmania promastigote antigen in an area that was equally co-endemic for trypanosomiasis, a cut-off titre of 1 : 3200 was found to be optimal (el Harith et al., 1988). However, a much lower cut-off value (1 : 400) could have been used in studies where the specificity of the DAT, due to 2-mercaptoethanol and urea incorporation, was remarkably enhanced, even versus Trypanosoma infections (el Harith et al., 1995).
Failure to demonstrate Leishmania parasite, even with repeated lymph node aspiration, in 8.7 % of the genuine VL cases in this study raises the question of whether negative parasitology can rule out VL (Boelaert et al., 1999). By employing relatively more sensitive parasitological methods such as spleen aspiration and choosing a cut-off value of twice that used here (1 : 6400), the DAT proved to be more sensitive (Veenken et al., 2003).
The marginally negative (1 : 8001 : 1600) or clearly negative (1 : 1001 : 400) titres obtained in eight (6.9 %) of our patients with positive lymph node (7) or spleen (1) aspirates is difficult to explain. A number of immunosuppressive conditions are commonly encountered in such remote areas in Sudan, such as malnutrition and tuberculosis, which could affect the results. Other predisposing conditions such as human immunodeficiency virus/AIDS cannot be ruled out, as we were not able to assess our suspected VL cases accordingly.
In conclusion, the GP antigen preparation demonstrated a high diagnostic efficiency and test reproducibility for VL comparable to the standard FF antigen and showed stability under high ambient temperatures similar to the FD antigen. It therefore has the potential to replace both antigens for use in rural hospitals.
| ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS |
|---|
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
D. Mansour, E. M. Abass, M. el Mutasim, A. Mahamoud, and A. el Harith Use of a Newly Developed -Mercaptoethanol Enzyme-Linked Immunosorbent Assay To Diagnose Visceral Leishmaniasis in Patients in Eastern Sudan Clin. Vaccine Immunol., December 1, 2007; 14(12): 1592 - 1595. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
E. M. Abass, D. Mansour, and A. el Harith Demonstration of agglutinating anti-Leishmania antibodies in lymph node aspirate for confirmation of kala-azar serodiagnosis J. Med. Microbiol., September 1, 2007; 56(9): 1256 - 1258. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| INT J SYST EVOL MICROBIOL | J MED MICROBIOL | MICROBIOLOGY | J GEN VIROL | ALL SGM JOURNALS |